What I Don't Know About Parenting
A few things to consider. This article was recently forwarded to me, as was this quote therefrom:
In [Dr. Richard Ferber's] best-selling 1985 book, "Solve Your Child's Sleep Problems," he advised parents to let babies cry for intervals of up to 45 minutes without responding, to train them to sleep on their own. Should the child cry so hard that he throws up, parents are to clean up and leave again. "If you reward him for throwing up by staying with him, he will only learn that this is a good way for him to get what he wants," Dr. Ferber wrote.
The party responsible for bringing this to my attention commented thusly:
My first question is - what is a person really learning when she is crying so hard she's throwing up and nobody is responding? My second question is - how deep is this belief that doing good can only be done by causing hurt?
I cannot help but conclude that the belief runs deep indeed. From spanking to capital punishment, from war to rapine and outright slaughter, doing good is the casus belli of choice. Those who come before us demanding that so-and-so must be destroyed for the good of mankind, that the decimation of the natural world serves a greater human good, or that punishment is a virtue and pain is a curative (other people's of course), and who thereafter view resistance to such ideas as a product of weakness, incompetence or willful disregard for uncomfortable truths - are simply wrong.
There are choices that we make. Often, these choices are informed by what we know will be, in the future, good for us. Sometimes we do bad or cruel things to achieve this future reward. Sometimes, however, we sacrifice a future gain because we're unwilling to be shitty, rotten, and despicable people. It's called character. Unfortunately, if you have character you may not live as long as someone else. You may not get a good job, have a nice car, or even the opportunity to raise a family. God knows you're going to suffer. Which, of course, would make you an idiot in the eyes of a society that is so addicted to pleasure that it literally kills for it.
I know the world can be a vicious and uncomfortable place. I know that mental and physical toughness are needed to get through it. If I choose not to endorse preemptive violence, "tough love", or a fuck-you attitude from time to time, it's not because I’m idealistic or naïve – it's simply because I choose not to debase my character. Or because I love someone or something. Which brings me back to the whole crying-so-hard-you-vomit business.
I believe that if a parent chooses to train their child to "self soothe", the child may very well be less fussy. If you respond to crying with love and affection, the child will eventually learn to manipulate that love – to use it against you. That's what happens when you love someone. You get burned. No doubt about it. It makes no difference who or what you love, it'll eventually result in horrible betrayal and unimaginable agony. Why? Because people are shit.
Eventually, the child will grow up and become a selfish adult. It's nature's way. But the child is only able to do that – we've only been able to become that – because somewhere along the way someone loved us enough to allow themselves to be rankly abused by our incessant demands for affection. Call it weakness if you will, it's nonetheless our only truly meaningful strength.








